Thu 11 Mar 2010
Book Review: Return Engagement (Settling Accounts, Book 1)
Posted by Jack under Books, Speculative Fiction
No Comments
Harry Turtledove scrambles history for us, taking situations from the first half of the 20th century and mixing them up geographically.
Imagine a dis-United States split into independent North and South with a breakaway state in the west. Great Britain attacking America, swirled alliances in Europe and warfare breaking out all over the place. Put the fascist governments in new locations with a different race as the scapegoat. Add fuel and ignite.
I think of it as World War II with an edge that we do not get in North America during History classes. The edge is that the worst fighting is happening at home – not overseas. It is civil war, world war, fascism, extremists, terrorism and sabotage rolled into one.
The first response when starting this book was antagonism – I felt like it was going to be cheap shots at sacred cows and not much character building or storyline. I am not too proud to admit I was wrong.
This book did develop some real characters. Perhaps overly flawed. Perhaps too real because of it. These characters became real enough to me that I understood their thought processes. I didn’t agree with them, but they were logical and understandable.
If all the characters were that real this book would earn a five star rating. Unfortunately, the cast of characters being developed was too big, and history was still being expounded upon towards the end of the book. Knowing that this is the first of a trilogy, it is easy to see how Mr. Turtledove is setting things up for the next books. I just wish it did not feel quite as formulaic.
Despite these complaints, I enjoyed this book and will probably look to the other two in the series if I ever run low on books to read.
4 stars.















